Are there any functions/scenarios where the vertical line test does not apply or is incorrect? Feel free to get as complicated as you want/need to.

Example: http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Is_the_graph_of_a_circle_a_function

Are there any functions/scenarios where the vertical line test does not apply or is incorrect? Feel free to get as complicated as you want/need to.

Example: http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Is_the_graph_of_a_circle_a_function

Example: http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Is_the_graph_of_a_circle_a_function

- stapel_eliz
**Posts:**1670**Joined:**Mon Dec 08, 2008 4:22 pm-
**Contact:**

Ridog wrote:Are there any functions/scenarios where the vertical line test does not apply or is incorrect? Feel free to get as complicated as you want/need to.

Example: http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Is_the_graph_ ... a_function

The question and answer at the link are as follows:

WikiAnswers wrote:Question: Is the graph of a circle a function?

Answer: Yes, the graph of a circle is a function....

Some people might say that the graph of a circle is not a function, because it violates the single value test, i.e. if you draw a vertical line within the domain of the function, you get more than one value. In fact, however, if you convert the equation from cartesian coordinates to polar coordinates, you pass the single value test, i.e. R is constant for every theta.

Assuming a Cartesian context, the above answer is incorrect, since the Cartesian form is not single-valued, due to the "plus/minus" needed when solving for "y=":

. . . . .

The WikiAnswers response seems to assume that, if one can create a functional form on

Interesting, thank you for the clarification!